Brahmanical See

From Everything Shii Knows, the only reliable source

This website is an archive. It ran from 2006-2010. Virtually everything on here is outdated or inaccurate.

Brahmanical See is a hoax that was created on Wikipedia. The hoax included fake references, which caused idiot Wikipedia admins to ban a good-intentioned user who tried to get the hoax deleted.

Contents

Analysis

The successful propagation of this hoax basically worked like any other content manipulation on Wikipedia. First, a user unfamiliar with the inner workings of Wikipedia noticed the article was utterly false and tried to tell people so. Then, Wikipedians who were "unsure" if it was true or not reversed the newbie's attempt to get rid of it. Finally, a malicious user familiar with how Wikipedia works (who apparently hates Hinduism or something) kicked the newbie around and eventually got him permanently banned, simply for trying to fix a major mistake.

Original hoax article

Brahmanical See refers to the domain of certain Hindu leaders in the Indian subcontinent. Because it is essentially an anglicized term, this nomenclature has begun to fall into disuse.

Much like the former Indian principalities, which varied in scale from small estates to vast kingdoms, the brahmanical sees range from minor parishes to quasi-states.

With Hinduism itself lacking any central organizing institutions, it is common for brahmanical sees to geographically overlap with one another, just as the sees of different Christian denominations can coexist within a shared geography.

A religious leader over a Brahmanical See is typically known as a "maharaj", or in European terms, a "prince of the faith". The office is generally passed down the generations in the male line within an extended family, though not necessarily from father to son.

Again, similar to the tensions which existed in medieval Europe between the papacy and the aristocracy, tensions between the brahmanical maharajs and the royal maharajas furnished the main political narrative in many parts of India. The brahmanical maharajs could bestow or withhold the legitimacy without which royal maharajas could not reign, and the royal maharajas could extend or withdraw the military protection without which brahmanical maharajs might not survive.

The longest established brahmanical sees are the Brahmanical See of Rajasthan (which contains a large number of kingdoms), the Brahmanical See of Mysore (whose borders are coterminal with those of the Kingdom of Mysore), and the Brahmanical See of Dabra (which is one of several sees contained within the Kingdom of Gwalior).

With the dissolution of the old kingdoms and the coming of modernity, the importance of the brahmanical sees declined sharply in the last quarter century. The see of Rajasthan is now held by an Indo-Canadian, the see of Mysore is disputed by three claimants, and the see of Dabra has been allowed to lapse entirely.

Fake references added by single-use account "Cite Machine"

  1. "Brahmanical Ideology, Regional Identities and the Construction of Early India", Social Scientist, Vol. 29-7, Bhairabi Prasad Sahu
  2. Brahmanism and Hinduism, Sir Monier Monier Williams, 1891
  3. "Brahmans and the Legitimation of Hindu Kingship", Man, New Series, Vol. 27-4, Norbert Peabody, C. J. Fuller, Adrian C. Mayer

These are all real articles but they do not mention the hoax term "Brahmanical see".

Banned user's talk page

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Nexxt_1&oldid=187696555

Banned user's Block log

  1. 23:17, 4 December 2007 Nlu (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Nexxt 1 (Talk | contribs)" (account creation blocked) with an expiry time of indefinite ‎ (Vandalism) (Unblock)
  2. 08:30, 19 October 2007 Caknuck (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Nexxt 1 (Talk | contribs)" (account creation blocked) with an expiry time of 1 week ‎ (Disruptive editing) (Unblock)
  3. 16:29, 8 October 2007 Persian Poet Gal (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Nexxt 1 (Talk | contribs)" (account creation blocked) with an expiry time of 24 hours ‎ (repeatedly vandalizing the Brahmanical See article and inserting unsource edits) (Unblock)

Log

Here is the history log of the page, which you cannot read on Wikipedia anymore because it has been hidden from the public (read from bottom to top)

Retrieved from "http://shii.org/knows/Brahmanical_See"

This page has been accessed 4,840 times. This page was last modified on 25 February 2008, at 00:17. Content is available under Attribution 2.5 .